At last I have gotten back to my sewing machine. The action was sheer bravado, a bit like pleine aire painting in Montana in December. We are still in the throes and throttles of repairs from the plumbing disaster. I had started a small quilted piece some time back and put it away until the repair mess was over. Then I lost it. But Wednesday night I found it again, and in a show of defiance against the universe that hid both the art and the sewing machine from sight, I unearthed the sewing machine and the thread, squeezed into the only space available to work in, and finished the piece. It felt good.
So now I can begin to ask the question, which is, is it worthwhile to take a painting and, by digitizing the image and printing it on silk, turn it into a quilted work of art? What are the benefits of doing so? What are the drawbacks?
Here are images of the two versions, oil painted and stitched silk, of The High Note.
The High Note, oil on board, 12 x 16

The High Note, about 22 x 30, digitized photograph on silk
I have some preliminary thoughts about putting the image on silk and stitching it. The textile piece looks different, not just because of the tactile and frieze-like nature of quilting, but because color takes differently with pigmented ink on silk than it does with oil on board. The image can be subtly changed through the stitching process, heightening or downplaying elements and thus changing something of the meaning of the oil work. On the other hand, printing the image, even on silk charmeuse, makes a less brilliant image than the original. And the image on textiles is less able to be tweaked when it's unsatisfactory. When you are finished, spending some amount of extra time and effort, you have a work that looks a lot like the other work -- is the time and effort worthwhile?
The uninitiated might ask, why not just paint with oils on silk or cotton rather than on board or stretched canvas? Well, oil paint eats fabric, unless the fabric is primed and gessoed and thereby rendered un-sewable. Nor can I manipulate fabric paints on un-gessoed fabric the way I can oil on board or canvas. The results on untreated fabric, even with fabric paints etc, are somewhat dummied down, simplified; the spread of the paint is very different when the surface is permeable, as it must be to sew on.
So this is the question I will be asking for the next couple of months. I think some of my paintings are more suited for turning into stitched art than others, but right now I don't have enough experience to tell which ones might be preferable. I sold the original oil painting of the images above, so I can't do an absolutely accurate assessment even of these two. But the next painting that I intend to stitch (another dog-and-High-Note) was not for sale, so I'll be able to judge the two side by side. And it's a more complex image, too, which could make a difference. Stay tuned..... -- June
Recent Comments